Best cigar reviews
Today we talk about Best cigar reviews.
As a passionate cigar enthusiast with years of exploration in hand-rolled delights, I’ve come to appreciate the exquisite flavors, craftsmanship, and sheer artistry that goes into making each cigar. According to a 2023 report from the Cigar Association of America, approximately 340 million cigars are consumed annually in the U.S. alone. This staggering figure only solidifies my belief that there is a cigar for everyone. Join me as I delve into some of the best cigar reviews based on my experiences, complete with details on flavor profiles, ratings, and what makes each selection unique.
Alec Bradley Fine & Rare A(11)-FYT
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The Alec Bradley Fine & Rare A(11)-FYT is a limited-edition gem that I simply couldn’t resist. This opulent cigar has garnered an impressive rating of 94 from Cigar Aficionado, and I wholeheartedly agree. I experienced a rich mix of flavors, from luscious cocoa to sweet cedar, enveloping my palate and providing a luxurious smoking experience. The cigar’s complexity is truly exceptional, featuring 10 different tobaccos, including a captivating Nicaraguan wrapper and Honduras binder. It stands out, especially for special occasions, with about 1,000 boxes released each year, making it a rarity to savor.
Alec Bradley Chunk Maduro
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The Alec Bradley Chunk Maduro has earned a strong reputation for its full-bodied profile. With a 92 rating from various cigar publications, it’s known for its luxurious notes of dark coffee and rich chocolate. The thick, oily wrapper contributes to its flavor explosion and makes it an excellent choice for those moments when you crave a robust smoke, like during a cold winter evening. What truly sets this cigar apart is its 60-ring gauge, which ensures a slow burn, giving me time to enjoy its hearty notes with a fine glass of bourbon—even at 6 inches long—it commands attention.
Macanudo Estate Reserve Flint Knoll Release No. 3
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The Macanudo Estate Reserve Flint Knoll Release No. 3 fascinated me with its elegant flavors. Priced at around $16 per cigar, it has maintained a strong following, especially among those who prefer a mild to medium profile. According to Cigar Insider, it garnered a 91 rating due to its smooth, creamy notes of toasted nuts and just enough spice to keep things interesting. I love reaching for this cigar during an afternoon spent outdoors, where its mellow nature harmonizes beautifully with a warm sun and a chilled drink.
Alec Bradley Black Market Filthy Ghooligan
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The Alec Bradley Black Market Filthy Ghooligan is a unique cigar that adds a bit of mischief to my collection. With an average rating of 90, it’s known for a mix of candied sweetness and peppery spice. The 5 x 46 vitola presents ample flavor without being overwhelming. I often think of this cigar during Halloween gatherings, as the name and flavor profiles evoke a festive atmosphere. Its combination of earthy and subtle fruity notes enhances an adventure that transforms a casual evening into a truly memorable occasion.
CAO Arcana Thunder Smoke
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The CAO Arcana Thunder Smoke is a personal favorite that grabs attention due to its boldness. Rated 91, it offers flavor notes ranging from full-bodied black pepper to a rich creaminess that lingers. It’s fascinating to learn from CAO that this particular release was crafted using cigars aged in a process similar to that of fine whiskey. Lighting this heavy-hitter makes me feel a rush of excitement—a perfect choice for late-night bonfires, where the flavors harmonize delightfully.
Diesel Fool’s Errand – Worthy Fool
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The Diesel Fool’s Errand – Worthy Fool has solidified its status as a remarkable selection with a 90+ rating. I found myself drawn to its dark, rich flavors of leather and wood, combined with sweet undertones that create an inviting experience. This cigar is priced around $10, which is reasonable for the depths of flavor it presents. Its complexity makes it perfect for enjoying while watching a late-night movie, as each puff transports me deeper into its captivating story.
Cohiba Weller By Cohiba 2024
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The Cohiba Weller By Cohiba 2024 is emblematic of luxury, boasting an average rating of 93. What captivated me was the mellow yet complex profile that features notes of sweet vanilla, bakery spices, and smooth oak, thanks to its aging in bourbon barrels. Priced at around $25, it certainly positions itself as a premium choice worth every penny. I often choose this for celebratory moments—a smooth cigar that pairs wonderfully with friends over a whiskey toast under the stars.
El Mago Cigars Disco
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
When enjoying the El Mago Cigars Disco, I’m welcomed into a world of creamy coffee and delightful fruity undertones—a mesmerizing blend that has gained a 91 rating from enthusiasts. This pick is roughly $15 and always exceeds my expectations. I recommend it for festive gatherings where I can share this delightful experience with others; its profile encourages camaraderie and connection with its rich flavors and smooth finish.
La Gloria Cubana Gran Legado
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The La Gloria Cubana Gran Legado offers a potent experience, rated at 92. As I savor it, flavors of dark chocolate and pepper resonate, making it a fulfilling choice for seasoned cigar lovers. This cigar is often priced between $10 and $12 and is perfect for those cool autumn evenings spent enjoying the calming sounds of nature, wrapped in warm layers filled with rich aroma.
Hoyo de Monterrey Oscuro
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The Hoyo de Monterrey Oscuro has a classic appeal—its 92 rating underscores the blend of deep, assorted tobaccos. I find fruit-forward notes and earthy undertones that create a symphony of flavors. With a price point around $8, it’s an affordable indulgence. This selection is often my go-to for a Friday night with a glass of dark rum, where the complementary flavors transport me to a tropical paradise.
Punch Dad’s Home Movies
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The Punch Dad’s Home Movies perfectly embodies nostalgia, echoing warmth and family. With an average rating of 90, its flavors of caramel and light spice resonate with me, creating a cozy vibe. Priced at $12 each, I enjoy this cigar during family gatherings, where laughter and stories abound, perfectly capturing the essence of shared memories.
Bolivar Cofradia Oscuro
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The Bolivar Cofradia Oscuro has carved out a solid reputation with a rating of 91. The complexity of flavors ranging from bold earthiness to sweet cocoa always impresses me. At a price point of around $9, it proves to be a great value for its robust character. I recommend this one during quiet evenings spent with meinen [my] favorite spirits, where the flavors enhance the experience with every puff.
Diesel Whiskey Row Founder’s Collection Mizunara
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The Diesel Whiskey Row Founder’s Collection Mizunara presents a captivating experience with an average rating of 92. The unique Mizunara oak aging brings out nuances of sandalwood and a hint of Japanese whiskey influence. Priced at $18, it is worth every dollar. I particularly love lighting this one during intimate gatherings, where its flavors create an inviting atmosphere that beckons deeper friendships.
CAO FASA Sol
Review Highlights and Flavor Profile
The CAO FASA Sol is a delightful choice that combines sweetness with unique hints of citrus and spice. I appreciate its refreshingly smooth profile, which earned it a score of 90. With an accessible price tag of about $10, it’s a perfect introduction to those just starting their journey into cigar enjoyment. I often reach for this one during summer barbecues, as it enhances the flavors of grilled delights wonderfully.
Top Cigar Picks for Beginners
Recommendations and Tasting Profiles
For newcomers to this wonderful world of cigars, I highly recommend starting with the following options that are both flavorful and approachable:
- Macanudo Café – Known for its creamy, mild nature, making it a perfect first pick.
- Romeo y Julieta 1875 – Classic with flavorful notes of cedar and spice, adored by many.
- Arturo Fuente Gran Reserva – Rich yet smooth, it serves as an ideal introduction to bold flavors.
Each of these selections offers a gentle introduction while ensuring you enjoy the best that cigar experiences can provide.
The Best Cigars Of The Year
Overview of 2023’s Top Cigars
In 2023, the cigar scene has seen remarkable releases that have garnered high acclaim. Notably, the Alec Bradley Fine & Rare A(11)-FYT and Cohiba Weller have maintained 90+ ratings across various platforms. These cigars incorporate flavorful profiles with quality craftsmanship, justifying their place as some of the best cigars of the year. As an avid smoker, the depth and elegance of these cigars have become a benchmark for what I expect from future releases.
Future Trends in Cigar Reviews
What to Expect in Upcoming Releases
Looking forward, I predict exciting trends emerging in cigar reviews. A focus on sustainable practices is gaining traction, with brands implementing eco-friendly production methods. Additionally, collaborations between distilleries and cigar artisans seem poised to offer new and creatively influenced blends. As a consumer, these developments make me excited about exploring fresh flavors while contributing to a more responsible industry at large.
FAQ
Which cigar brand is the best?
While the “best” brand can vary per individual taste, Cohiba, Padron, and Arturo Fuente consistently rank among the finest due to their exceptional quality and craftsmanship in the cigar industry.
What is the smoothest cigar in the world?
The Macanudo Café often stands out as one of the smoothest cigars, offering a gentle smoking experience that’s perfect for both new and experienced smokers alike.
What is the highest rating for a cigar?
Cigar ratings can peak as high as 100, but many celebrated cigars maintain a high standard with consistent ratings above 90 across various publications and reviews.
Are Cuban cigars actually the best?
Cuban cigars hold a legendary reputation, cherished for their quality and craftsmanship, but many non-Cuban cigars offer exceptional quality that can stand toe-to-toe with their legendary counterparts.
